The work behind this perspective

As an FP&A Consultant at Galloway, I automated recurring monthly sponsor data requests across net revenue, labor hours, employee billing, and operating expenses through self-service Power BI reporting developed with AI, and enabled one-click refresh of key VCP metrics. The sections that follow set out my recommended validation approach for finance analysis and reporting.

Choose checks that match the task

Specify the inputs, requested output, and intended audience. Establish what a reviewer must verify and what should be flagged as unresolved. The three example tasks below call for different checks; using one general instruction to review everything leaves the standard unclear.

Recommended checks for three finance tasks
TaskReview focus
QoE rollforwardReconcile the starting position, movements, and ending position; identify adjustment sources and unresolved differences.
Backlog analysisConfirm the snapshot date, project population, and backlog definition; trace material figures to the source.
Monthly reporting commentaryCheck quantified statements against the reporting package; distinguish supported causes from proposed explanations.

Resolve definitions before interpretation

Make the period, business population, units, sign conventions, and adjustment treatments explicit. Backlog should mean the same thing to the workflow and the reviewer. An organic-growth explanation should use the intended entity comparison. When source reports use different definitions, resolve the difference or show it as an open question.

Keep important figures traceable to the relevant source file, table, or record. Missing information should remain visible. If an assumption is necessary, label it and distinguish it from a sourced fact. This gives the reviewer a route back to the evidence instead of asking them to trust the final prose.

Test the explanation, not just the total

Reconciliation checks arithmetic and completeness within the defined task. It does not prove the proposed cause of a movement. An increase associated with a change in the reporting population should not become an unsupported claim about stronger demand.

Review unusual movements, changed mappings, new entities, and incomplete inputs, while also inspecting ordinary items. Ask whether the explanation matches the comparison basis and whether alternative interpretations remain plausible. Where the evidence supports only an observation, keep the language at that level.

If the same error recurs, address the definition, mapping, or instruction that produces it. Repeatedly correcting the final paragraph leaves the underlying workflow unchanged.

Fictional example: a total that ties can still be wrong

Illustrative Services Co. is a fictional $200 million-scale business. Its September actual revenue of $16.72 million is equivalent to about $201 million annualized; that annualization is a scale reference, not a full-year forecast. Every number, source record, AI response, and reviewer action in this worked example is invented for teaching purposes. The AI draft is simulated; it is not the output of an executed tool or a client engagement.

The task is to explain September 2026 actual EBITDA against September budget for the same single entity. All figures in the tables are $000. For this simplified example, revenue, delivery payroll, and overhead are the only operating revenue and expense categories; interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization are excluded. There are no acquisitions, adjustments, or changes in the reporting population.

The fictional input pack has three records: A, the September income statement below; B, a delivery payroll schedule matching its payroll balances; and C, an initiative tracker projecting $120,000 of monthly automation savings from November, with implementation still marked pending. Forecast savings are outside this September actual-versus-budget bridge.

Fictional September budget and actual income statement, $000
Income statement lineBudgetActual
Revenue16,00016,720
Delivery payroll expense8,8008,960
Overhead expense3,2003,280
EBITDA4,0004,480

Reconcile each component, not only the ending balance

The simulated AI bridge overstates the revenue effect by $240,000 and makes the payroll effect $240,000 too negative. These two extraction errors cancel: both bridges arrive at $4,480,000 of EBITDA. Comparing only the ending balance would miss both errors.

Each bridge component is its effect on EBITDA. Revenue uses actual minus budget; expense lines use budget minus actual, so higher costs have a negative effect. With all operating expenses shown separately and no other changes in this simplified business, the $720,000 revenue increase is the revenue component of the EBITDA bridge.

Simulated AI bridge compared with source-verified fictional bridge, $000
Bridge componentSimulated AISource-verifiedAI minus verified
Budget EBITDA4,0004,0000
Revenue effect+960+720+240
Delivery payroll effect−400−160−240
Overhead effect−80−800
Net EBITDA movement+480+4800
Actual EBITDA4,4804,4800

Resolve exceptions before using the commentary

The simulated AI also writes: “Revenue growth reflects stronger customer demand. Automation delivered $120,000 in monthly overhead savings.” Neither assertion is supported by the fictional input pack. An income statement identifies the revenue movement but does not establish whether demand, pricing, or mix caused it. The tracker describes a future forecast, not a realized September saving.

The fictional reviewers resolve the numerical errors and remove the unsupported claims. Questions that need more evidence remain assigned follow-ups.

Fictional exception log, evidence, and accountable resolution
ExceptionEvidenceResolution and owner
Revenue effect overstated by $240kRecord A: 16,720 − 16,000 = +720.FP&A lead replaces +960 with +720; controller verifies the source period and revenue mapping.
Payroll effect too negative by $240kRecords A and B: 8,800 − 8,960 = −160.FP&A lead replaces −400 with −160; controller verifies payroll completeness and signs.
Stronger demand presented as a causeRecords A–C contain no customer volume, pricing, or mix evidence.CFO removes the causal claim; commercial lead is assigned the driver analysis.
Forecast savings presented as realizedRecord C projects $120k per month from November; implementation is pending.CFO removes the realized-savings claim; operations must confirm implementation, and FP&A must validate actual savings against a defined baseline.

Approve the verified result and retain the open questions

The verified bridge is $4,000k + $720k − $160k − $80k = $4,480k. It agrees with the actual income statement: $16,720k − $8,960k − $3,280k = $4,480k. The difference to the source EBITDA is zero, and each component now matches its source.

In this example, the controller verifies the figures and the CFO approves this wording for the reporting package: “September EBITDA was $4.48 million, $480,000 above budget. Revenue was $720,000 above budget, partly offset by $160,000 of additional delivery payroll and $80,000 of additional overhead.”

The cause of the revenue increase and the realization of automation savings remain unverified. They stay in the follow-up log with their assigned owners. The review record retains the input versions, definition of the comparison, two corrected figures, removed claims, and approval. The example illustrates my recommended review method; it does not claim a measured result from my client work.

Give a person responsibility for its use

Identify who approves the output and what that approval covers. Preparing analysis, distributing management reporting, and making an operating decision are distinct responsibilities. Define the review needed for the intended audience and how unresolved issues will be communicated.

Retain enough context to explain which inputs, definitions, and material corrections produced the result. Reconsider the checks when the source data or task changes. A familiar output format should not conceal a changed analytical problem.

A practical review before use

Before using the output, I recommend that the responsible reviewer answer these questions. An unresolved answer should become a specific follow-up or a clearly stated limit on how the output can be used.

  • Can material figures be traced and reconciled to the defined inputs?
  • Do the definitions and comparison periods match the question being asked?
  • Are causal explanations supported, with assumptions and uncertainty visible?
  • Does the accountable reviewer understand the intended audience and use?